I asked a similar question about atlases. My husband's old trucker's atlas (circa 2004) is excellent, but we are thinking it needs to be replaced due to age. The other atlas needs to be replaced because it is horribly falling apart. We are still torn between a cheap Rand McNally from Wal-Mart and going with a newer version of the trucker's atlas. The problem is, we really don't need all the extra info that the trucker atlas gives. But we love the laminated pages. (The non-laminated atlas has splotches all over it from splashing coffee, despite the use of commuter mugs!)
Donna