Credit, where credit is due.
Michael, don't let me take all the credit for that choice. It was at the suggestion of our friend and colleague, glc, that I knew how to go about getting an independent report. The problem with getting a local mechanic was, that I do not know who is a buddy of the seller, and I could end up with a report which is not so independent. Speaking with said member, we decided that the best way to go was through the local dealership. It's actually located in your general direction. Just 50 miles south of Chicago.
Lifey
Nice work. Reading between the lines.......
.........it appears NAIS is a national agency which contracts with local independent mechanics and body shops to do the inspections, so your concerns about possible conflicts of interest between a seller and a local shop seem to still be present. I do not perceive NAIS to be a business with a physical presence in Cities A, B, and C. On the contrary, I imagine the local mechanic's shops and body shops contracted to NAIS field a phone call or email from NAIS, drive a short distance to the seller's location, whip out a quick report, and are back at their shop in < 1 hour. With ASE and qualified shop hourly labor rates running $75-100/hour, or more, I can not envision contracted inspectors devoting much time to these tasks.
In looking through the FAQs, I see the inspector will NOT personally test-drive the vehicle, but instead MAY do a ride-along for UP TO 5 miles. I personally find it hard to evaluate steering, braking, suspension behavior, transmission behavior on a ride-along, and 5 miles strikes me as a short test-drive.
The inspectors only inspect the underside of the vehicle IF the seller has a lift and IF the seller agrees to lift the vehicle.
There is no opportunity for a compression test.
All of that said, I find the fee to be entirely reasonable and an inspection via NAIS to be far, far better than none at all. With a dealership seller, I'd want assurances the inspector would have access to the underside of the vehicle via the dealership's lift. I would absolutely require same where a vehicle owned/used in snow/ice/salt country is concerned, as there seems to be no way to evaluate levels of corrosion related to winter use in northern climes absent an up-close look underneath.
Glad to see you're making progress, Lifey. Wish I could be more help.
Foy