Never spilled coffee on it
I like the laminated one -- not because I'd ever allow anyone to spill coffee in my truck... but because it holds up under the stress of having my laptop case, two cameras, assorted flotsam and jetsam that seems to gravitate to the floor behind my seat and some assorted gear and clothes that somehow is often sitting on my maps. I like all of that extra trucking information as well -- keeps me looking at stuff I'd miss otherwise.
There are only two things I tend to collect... maps and flashlights. I have a few dozen of each.... (Most of my map collection is framed and hangs on walls though.) My working road trip map collection is comprised of only about 12 maps!
Mark